Most people pick a plan by scanning monthly premiums, which is the one number that says the least about what a year of coverage will cost. Work through these five steps in order instead.
1. Write down the care you used last year
Count office visits, specialists, therapy sessions, imaging, procedures, and every prescription you refill. Next year is rarely identical, but last year is the best estimate you have, and it turns an abstract comparison into arithmetic.
2. Check that your doctors are in network
Networks are set per plan, not per insurer, so the same company can sell one plan your doctor accepts and another they do not. Look up each provider in the plan directory, then call the office and confirm they take that exact plan for the coming year.
3. Check that your drugs are on the formulary
Search each medication on the plan drug list and note the tier it lands on, whether prior authorization or step therapy applies, and whether a preferred pharmacy is required. A plan that leaves one of your maintenance drugs off the list can cost more than a higher premium would have.
4. Compare total cost, not premium
For each plan, add twelve months of premium to the care you expect to pay for before the plan starts paying. Then look at the out-of-pocket maximum, which is the worst case if the year goes badly. A plan with a higher premium and a much lower maximum can be the cheaper choice for someone who uses a lot of care.
5. Check what help you qualify for
If you buy your own coverage, a premium tax credit may lower your monthly cost, and cost-sharing reductions can lower your deductible and copays if your income qualifies and you choose a Silver plan. Eligibility depends on income, household size, and where you live, so the only reliable answer comes from checking plans for your own address.
Related: how marketplace plans and metal tiers work.